xmlsec: signing the document fails the 3rd time (invalid signature)

Signing the document 3 or more times produces an invalid signature.
The cause of this is that xmlsec is confused because we have 3
signatures, which all have the same SignedProperties with the ID
"idSignedProperties", but it expect them to be unique.

This issue is fixed by making the ID unique with adding the ID of
the Signature to the SignedProperties ID, so this makes them unique
inside the same Signature.

Also UnsignedProperties have a unique ID usign the same approach,
but they aren't referenced - luckily.

Change-Id: I53c7249a82fc0623586548db9fa25bdc0e7c4101
Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/124278
Tested-by: Jenkins
Reviewed-by: Tomaž Vajngerl <quikee@gmail.com>

5 files changed, 152 insertions, 23 deletions

diff --git a/xmlsecurity/qa/unit/signing/signing.cxx b/xmlsecurity/qa/unit/signing/signing.cxx
index 62c56a625ac3..ed50ade74bf8 100644
--- a/xmlsecurity/qa/unit/signing/signing.cxx
+++ b/xmlsecurity/qa/unit/signing/signing.cxx
@@ -981,13 +981,13 @@ CPPUNIT_TEST_FIXTURE(SigningTest, testXAdESNotype)
     // attribute", i.e. the signature without such an attribute was not preserved correctly.
     assertXPathNoAttribute(pXmlDoc,
                            "/odfds:document-signatures/dsig:Signature[1]/dsig:SignedInfo/"
-                           "dsig:Reference[@URI='#idSignedProperties']",
+                           "dsig:Reference[starts-with(@URI, '#idSignedProperties')]",
                            "Type");
 
     // New signature always has the Type attribute.
     assertXPath(pXmlDoc,
                 "/odfds:document-signatures/dsig:Signature[2]/dsig:SignedInfo/"
-                "dsig:Reference[@URI='#idSignedProperties']",
+                "dsig:Reference[starts-with(@URI, '#idSignedProperties')]",
                 "Type", "http://uri.etsi.org/01903#SignedProperties");
 }
 
@@ -1046,12 +1046,132 @@ CPPUNIT_TEST_FIXTURE(SigningTest, testXAdES)
     // Assert that the digest of the signing certificate is included.
     assertXPath(pXmlDoc, "//xd:CertDigest", 1);
 
-    // Assert that the Type attribute on the idSignedProperties reference is
-    // not missing.
-    assertXPath(pXmlDoc,
-                "/odfds:document-signatures/dsig:Signature/dsig:SignedInfo/"
-                "dsig:Reference[@URI='#idSignedProperties']",
-                "Type", "http://uri.etsi.org/01903#SignedProperties");
+    // Assert that the Type attribute is set on all URI's that start with #idSignedProperties
+    assertXPath(pXmlDoc, "//dsig:Reference[starts-with(@URI, '#idSignedProperties')]", "Type",
+                "http://uri.etsi.org/01903#SignedProperties");
+}
+
+CPPUNIT_TEST_FIXTURE(SigningTest, testSigningMultipleTimes_ODT)
+{
+    createDoc("");
+
+    utl::TempFile aTempFile;
+    aTempFile.EnableKillingFile();
+    uno::Reference<frame::XStorable> xStorable(mxComponent, uno::UNO_QUERY);
+    utl::MediaDescriptor aMediaDescriptor;
+    aMediaDescriptor["FilterName"] <<= OUString("writer8");
+    xStorable->storeAsURL(aTempFile.GetURL(), aMediaDescriptor.getAsConstPropertyValueList());
+
+    DocumentSignatureManager aManager(mxComponentContext, DocumentSignatureMode::Content);
+    CPPUNIT_ASSERT(aManager.init());
+    uno::Reference<embed::XStorage> xStorage
+        = comphelper::OStorageHelper::GetStorageOfFormatFromURL(
+            ZIP_STORAGE_FORMAT_STRING, aTempFile.GetURL(), embed::ElementModes::READWRITE);
+    CPPUNIT_ASSERT(xStorage.is());
+    aManager.setStore(xStorage);
+    aManager.getSignatureHelper().SetStorage(xStorage, "1.2");
+
+    // Create a signature.
+    uno::Reference<security::XCertificate> xCertificate
+        = getCertificate(aManager, svl::crypto::SignatureMethodAlgorithm::RSA);
+    if (!xCertificate.is())
+        return;
+    sal_Int32 nSecurityId;
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, /*rDescription=*/OUString(), nSecurityId,
+                 /*bAdESCompliant=*/true);
+
+    // Read back the signature and make sure that it's valid.
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(1), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[0].nStatus);
+    }
+
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, /*rDescription=*/OUString(), nSecurityId,
+                 /*bAdESCompliant=*/true);
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(2), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[1].nStatus);
+    }
+
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, /*rDescription=*/OUString(), nSecurityId,
+                 /*bAdESCompliant=*/true);
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(3), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[2].nStatus);
+    }
+}
+
+CPPUNIT_TEST_FIXTURE(SigningTest, testSigningMultipleTimes_OOXML)
+{
+    createDoc("");
+
+    utl::TempFile aTempFile;
+    aTempFile.EnableKillingFile();
+    uno::Reference<frame::XStorable> xStorable(mxComponent, uno::UNO_QUERY);
+    utl::MediaDescriptor aMediaDescriptor;
+    aMediaDescriptor["FilterName"] <<= OUString("MS Word 2007 XML");
+    xStorable->storeAsURL(aTempFile.GetURL(), aMediaDescriptor.getAsConstPropertyValueList());
+
+    DocumentSignatureManager aManager(mxComponentContext, DocumentSignatureMode::Content);
+    CPPUNIT_ASSERT(aManager.init());
+    uno::Reference<embed::XStorage> xStorage
+        = comphelper::OStorageHelper::GetStorageOfFormatFromURL(
+            ZIP_STORAGE_FORMAT_STRING, aTempFile.GetURL(), embed::ElementModes::READWRITE);
+    CPPUNIT_ASSERT(xStorage.is());
+    aManager.setStore(xStorage);
+    aManager.getSignatureHelper().SetStorage(xStorage, "1.2");
+
+    // Create a signature.
+    uno::Reference<security::XCertificate> xCertificate
+        = getCertificate(aManager, svl::crypto::SignatureMethodAlgorithm::ECDSA);
+    if (!xCertificate.is())
+        return;
+
+    sal_Int32 nSecurityId;
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, "", nSecurityId, /*bAdESCompliant=*/false);
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(1), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[0].nStatus);
+    }
+
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, "", nSecurityId, /*bAdESCompliant=*/false);
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(2), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[1].nStatus);
+    }
+
+    aManager.add(xCertificate, mxSecurityContext, "", nSecurityId, /*bAdESCompliant=*/false);
+    aManager.read(/*bUseTempStream=*/true);
+    {
+        std::vector<SignatureInformation>& rInformations
+            = aManager.getCurrentSignatureInformations();
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(static_cast<std::size_t>(3), rInformations.size());
+        CPPUNIT_ASSERT_EQUAL(css::xml::crypto::SecurityOperationStatus_OPERATION_SUCCEEDED,
+                             rInformations[2].nStatus);
+    }
+    aManager.write(/*bXAdESCompliantIfODF=*/true);
+    uno::Reference<embed::XTransactedObject> xTransactedObject(xStorage, uno::UNO_QUERY);
+    xTransactedObject->commit();
 }
 
 /// Works with an existing good XAdES signature.
diff --git a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/documentsignaturehelper.cxx b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/documentsignaturehelper.cxx
index c222824376a5..77288e299cff 100644
--- a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/documentsignaturehelper.cxx
+++ b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/documentsignaturehelper.cxx
@@ -528,7 +528,7 @@ void DocumentSignatureHelper::writeSignedProperties(
 {
     {
         rtl::Reference<SvXMLAttributeList> pAttributeList(new SvXMLAttributeList());
-        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Id", "idSignedProperties");
+        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Id", "idSignedProperties_" + signatureInfo.ouSignatureId);
         xDocumentHandler->startElement("xd:SignedProperties", uno::Reference<xml::sax::XAttributeList>(pAttributeList));
     }
 
diff --git a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/ooxmlsecexporter.cxx b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/ooxmlsecexporter.cxx
index a202cda19cef..4cdf82ef8561 100644
--- a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/ooxmlsecexporter.cxx
+++ b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/ooxmlsecexporter.cxx
@@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ void OOXMLSecExporter::Impl::writeSignedInfoReferences()
         {
             {
                 rtl::Reference<SvXMLAttributeList> pAttributeList(new SvXMLAttributeList());
-                if (rReference.ouURI != "idSignedProperties")
+                if (!rReference.ouURI.startsWith("idSignedProperties"))
                     pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Type",
                                                  "http://www.w3.org/2000/09/xmldsig#Object");
                 else
@@ -172,7 +172,7 @@ void OOXMLSecExporter::Impl::writeSignedInfoReferences()
                 m_xDocumentHandler->startElement(
                     "Reference", uno::Reference<xml::sax::XAttributeList>(pAttributeList));
             }
-            if (rReference.ouURI == "idSignedProperties")
+            if (rReference.ouURI.startsWith("idSignedProperties"))
             {
                 m_xDocumentHandler->startElement(
                     "Transforms",
diff --git a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecctl.cxx b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecctl.cxx
index a43b2abacbd6..e793be4337f2 100644
--- a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecctl.cxx
+++ b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecctl.cxx
@@ -532,7 +532,7 @@ void writeUnsignedProperties(
 {
     {
         rtl::Reference<SvXMLAttributeList> pAttributeList(new SvXMLAttributeList());
-        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Id", "idUnsignedProperties");
+        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Id", "idUnsignedProperties_" + signatureInfo.ouSignatureId);
         xDocumentHandler->startElement("xd:UnsignedProperties", uno::Reference<xml::sax::XAttributeList>(pAttributeList));
     }
 
@@ -649,16 +649,21 @@ void XSecController::exportSignature(
                  * same-document reference
                  */
                 {
-                    pAttributeList->AddAttribute(
+                    if (refInfor.ouURI.startsWith("idSignedProperties"))
+                    {
+                        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("URI", "#idSignedProperties_" + signatureInfo.ouSignatureId);
+                        if (bXAdESCompliantIfODF && !refInfor.ouType.isEmpty())
+                        {
+                            // The reference which points to the SignedProperties
+                            // shall have this specific type.
+                            pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Type", refInfor.ouType);
+                        }
+                    }
+                    else
+                    {
+                        pAttributeList->AddAttribute(
                         "URI",
                         "#" + refInfor.ouURI);
-
-                    if (bXAdESCompliantIfODF && refInfor.ouURI == "idSignedProperties" && !refInfor.ouType.isEmpty())
-                    {
-                        // The reference which points to the SignedProperties
-                        // shall have this specific type.
-                        pAttributeList->AddAttribute("Type",
-                                                     refInfor.ouType);
                     }
                 }
 
diff --git a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecsign.cxx b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecsign.cxx
index 5b3eb6fa266b..76460d906c90 100644
--- a/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecsign.cxx
+++ b/xmlsecurity/source/helper/xsecsign.cxx
@@ -135,8 +135,9 @@ css::uno::Reference< css::xml::crypto::sax::XReferenceResolvedListener > XSecCon
 
         if (bXAdESCompliantIfODF)
         {
+            OUString aId = "idSignedProperties_" +  internalSignatureInfor.signatureInfor.ouSignatureId;
             // We write a new reference, so it's possible to use the correct type URI.
-            internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, "idSignedProperties", -1, "http://uri.etsi.org/01903#SignedProperties");
+            internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, aId, -1, "http://uri.etsi.org/01903#SignedProperties");
             size++;
         }
 
@@ -148,13 +149,16 @@ css::uno::Reference< css::xml::crypto::sax::XReferenceResolvedListener > XSecCon
             size++;
         }
     }
-    else
+    else // OOXML
     {
+        internalSignatureInfor.signatureInfor.ouSignatureId = "idPackageSignature";
+
         internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, "idPackageObject", -1, OUString());
         size++;
         internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, "idOfficeObject", -1, OUString());
         size++;
-        internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, "idSignedProperties", -1, OUString());
+        OUString aId = "idSignedProperties_" +  internalSignatureInfor.signatureInfor.ouSignatureId;
+        internalSignatureInfor.addReference(SignatureReferenceType::SAMEDOCUMENT, digestID, aId, -1, OUString());
         size++;
     }